← Patterns

Minto Pyramid Principle

Pattern · communication

Core Concept

Structure communication answer-first using SCQA, then support with evidence in pyramid form. The reader/listener should get the punchline immediately and can drill into supporting arguments as needed.

SCQA Framework:

• Situation: The state of affairs — fact-based, unambiguous
• Complication: The thing that’s changed, what makes things harder
• Question: The question raised by S and C
• Answer: The answer to Q in pyramid form — answer first, then supporting evidence

What Makes Good SCQA

SCQ (the setup):

• Non-controversial, easy to accept
• Comprehensive of necessary background information
• Question begs for resolution of the complication

A (the answer):

• Based on evidence
• Modular and presented in series
• Resolves the complication directly

Example

Narrative style (bad):

“We’re doing OK in the watches category but not as great as we could be doing…”

Minto-ized (good):

• S: Watches category is critical to our growth strategy. It’s 15% of our sales and a gateway category for jewelry and shoes.
• C: Repeat purchase rates are down 10% versus last month.
• Q: What should we do?
• A: Let’s —
  1. Increase cross-marketing of other categories in email [evidence]
  2. Accelerate release of two new sub-categories [evidence]
  3. Do a price-promo to lapsed buyers test [evidence]

Why It Matters

Communicating poorly stunts your career and your growth. Doing it well opens up opportunities. Great storytelling appeals to both the rational and intuitive parts of the brain — it leaves a lasting impression by reinforcing or directly challenging ideas about ourselves, the world, or the future.

“Barbara Minto is your new best friend.” — Michael Dearing

Where I’ve Used It

• Performance reviews and self-assessments — lead with the rating, then evidence
• Engineering proposals — state the recommendation, then the analysis
• Communicating Technical Complexity — SCQA + Options Table is the core structure for presenting technical trade-offs to stakeholders
• Tricky Situation Adventure Cards — “Minto’s Pyramid Principle” is one of the 21 management situation cards

Related Patterns

• Leadership as Performance — communication IS a performance skill
• Executive Presence — structured communication projects confidence

Cross-References